Lawyers for Idaho and Washington news organizations argue that the public should be able to know results of the psychological exam that will help decide whether admitted murderer Joseph Duncan is competent to act as his own attorney in his federal sentencing hearing.
In a motion filed in federal court in Boise, the groups also are urging U.S. District Judge Edward Lodge to unseal several documents that discuss why testimony from one of Duncan’s victims, Shasta Groene, should be heard in a closed courtroom.
The Spokesman-Review, the Associated Press, and other newspapers and television stations are challenging an effort to exclude the public from Duncan’s sentencing hearing if Shasta takes the stand, or the jury is shown a video taken of the torture and murder of her 9-year-old brother, Dylan.
Duncan faces life in prison or the death penalty for the 2005 kidnapping and molestation of the two children, and killing of Dylan.
Jury selection for the hearing is on hold until Lodge decides whether to grant Duncan’s request to serve as his own attorney. As part of that decision, the judge ordered a Boise psychologist to examine Duncan and report whether he is competent to represent himself. Lodge’s order for the exam indicates it will be kept from the public once it is filed.
Prosecution and defense attorneys are under a judge’s gag order that prohibits them from discussing the case.
(The Spokesman-Review)